Explore unexplained.im

Wiseman et al., 2003

What did the researchers find?

The paper is reported in its own wording. Historic Royal Palaces later summarised the same work in a different way; that later wording is kept on the palace page, not quietly mixed into these results.

The astronomical clock on a red-brick turret at Hampton Court Palace
The clock in Clock Court at Hampton Court Palace, photographed by Mike Cattell on 11 April 2010. The Wikimedia Commons file is titled Hampton Court Astrological Clock. The file is CC BY 2.0. Photo: Mike Cattell, 11 April 2010 · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Wiseman, Watt, Stevens, Greening and O’Keeffe published “An investigation into alleged ‘hauntings’” in the British Journal of Psychology, volume 94, pages 195–211, doi 10.1348/000712603321661886. Experiments were run at Hampton Court Palace and the South Bridge Vaults. Participants walked around and reported where they experienced unusual phenomena. [source]

The abstract’s own result is the one quoted here. “Results revealed significantly more reports of unusual experiences in areas that had a reputation for being haunted. This effect was not related to participants’ prior knowledge about the reputation of these areas. However, the location of participants’ experiences correlated significantly with various environmental factors, including, for example, the variance of local magnetic fields and lighting levels. These findings strongly suggest that alleged hauntings may not necessarily represent evidence for ‘ghostly’ activity, but could be, at least in part, the result of people responding to ‘normal’ factors in their surroundings.” [source]

A late-nineteenth-century book illustration of the Haunted Gallery at Hampton Court Palace
The Haunted Gallery at Hampton Court Palace, illustrated by Herbert Railton in 1897. This is a book illustration, not a photograph of a ghost. Historic Royal Palaces notes that early 1900s postcards were faked double-exposed photographs offered as ‘proof’. The file is in the public domain. Illustration: Herbert Railton, 1897 · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Experiment 1, Hampton Court

The palace experiment ran in “late May/early June 2000.” Visitors were self-selecting people who had seen leaflets, and they knew they were taking part in a scientific investigation. There were 18 sessions over 6 days, with a maximum of 40 people a session. “There were 678 participants who each attended 1 of the 18 sessions.” After exclusions for incomplete questionnaires (131 then 85), “the number of participants remaining was 462 (163 males, 299 females; mean age: 35.0, age range: 7 to 82, SD= 16.3).” [source]

There were 431 unusual experiences: 189 (43.8%) in the Haunted Gallery and 242 (56.2%) in the Georgian Rooms. 215 participants (46.5%) reported at least one experience; among those, the mean was 2.0 (SD 1.45). “Approximately two thirds of these experiences involved an unusual change in temperature.” The remaining third included dizziness, headaches, sickness, shortness of breath, some form of ‘force’, a foul odour, a sense of presence and intense emotional feelings. [source]

The red-brick Tudor west front of Hampton Court Palace, with tall chimneys and a small grassed court, under a clear blue sky
The west front of Hampton Court Palace, photographed by Tilman2007 on 23 August 2023. The file is CC BY-SA 4.0 and is used on the website only, not in the typographic fact sheets. Photo: Tilman2007, 23 August 2023 · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons

Asked whether the experiences were due to a ghost: 8 (3.72%) ‘Definitely yes’, 22 (10.23%) ‘Probably yes’, 80 (37.21%) ‘Uncertain’, 87 (40.46%) ‘Probably no’, 18 (8.37%) ‘Definitely no’. The authors stated a chance baseline: “By chance, it was expected that approximately 29% of participants’ unusual experiences would be reported in the ‘haunted’ areas of the Haunted Gallery, and 25% in the Georgian Rooms. However, groups of participants visiting both rooms reported significantly more unusual experiences in the ‘haunted’ areas within both locations.” Prior knowledge “was not significantly related to the percentage of experiences reported” in those areas. [source]

Magnetic field strength was not significantly different (1-sample t(32) = .82, p = .42). “The variance of the local magnetic field was significantly greater in ‘haunted’ than ‘control’ areas,” and there was a significant relationship between that variance and the mean number of unusual experiences. [source]

Belief-in-ghosts items from Questionnaire 1 are referred by the authors to a separate 2002 paper in the Journal of Parapsychology. This site does not treat Historic Royal Palaces’ later sentence, “believers reported more spooky sensations overall,” as a finding quoted from the 2003 results section. [source] [source]

South Bridge in Edinburgh, a street of shops built on a bridge, under a pale sky
South Bridge, Edinburgh, photographed by Matti Blume. The 2003 paper’s second experiment was conducted in ten of the South Bridge Vaults. The file is CC BY-SA 4.0 and is used on the website only. Photo: Matti Blume · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons

Experiment 2, and a shared conclusion

The vaults experiment is told in full on the vaults page. The discussion of both studies is short and consistent: “The results of Expts 1 and 2 are highly consistent, with around 45% of participants in each experiment reporting at least one unusual experience.” [source]

Keep exploring

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this hauntings desk?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next unexplained.im site get built.