Explore unexplained.im

Ten rooms under a bridge

The Edinburgh vaults: a haunted order, and ten minutes alone

The 2003 paper’s second experiment took place in ten of the South Bridge Vaults. This page reports what that methods section itself states, and does not invent an earlier slum history from unread citations.

South Bridge in Edinburgh, a street of shops built on a bridge, under a pale sky
South Bridge, Edinburgh, photographed by Matti Blume. The 2003 paper’s second experiment was conducted in ten of the South Bridge Vaults. The file is CC BY-SA 4.0 and is used on the website only. Photo: Matti Blume · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons

A senior tour guide, Fran Hollinrake, ranked the ten vaults from 1 (“least haunted”) to 10 (“most haunted”) from the tour company’s collection of unusual-experience reports. The authors called that ranking the “Haunted Order.” [source]

A dim, stone-vaulted chamber in the Edinburgh vaults, with a bare electric bulb
A chamber in the Edinburgh vaults, photographed by Kjetil Bjørnsrud in 2005. The Commons filename is Edinburgh_valuts_1.jpg, with a typo in ‘vaults’. The 2003 paper’s second experiment took place in ten of the South Bridge Vaults. The file is CC BY 2.5 and is used on the website only. Photo: Kjetil Bjørnsrud, 2005 · CC BY 2.5 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons

Participants (N = 218; 91 males, 127 females; mean age 35.3, range 11 to 77) attended one of 24 sessions, in groups of up to ten, and “spent approximately 10 minutes in one vault on their own.” There were 172 unusual experiences. Ninety-five participants (43.58%) reported at least one; among those, the mean was 1.81 (SD .94). [source]

Another stone chamber in the Edinburgh vaults, lit by a single bulb
A second view of the Edinburgh vaults, photographed by Kjetil Bjørnsrud in 2005. The Commons filename is Edinburgh_valuts_2.jpg. The file is CC BY 2.5 and is used on the website only. Photo: Kjetil Bjørnsrud, 2005 · CC BY 2.5 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons

The correlation of the Haunted Order with the mean number of experiences was N = 10, rho = .76, p = .02. After the researchers excluded 31 participants who said “yes” or “uncertain” about prior knowledge of where unusual phenomena had been experienced, the remaining correlation was rho = .87, p = .009. [source]

Looking along South Bridge in Edinburgh, with shops and traffic under a grey sky
South Bridge, Edinburgh, photographed by Rept0n1x. The file is CC BY-SA 3.0 and is used on the website only. Photo: Rept0n1x · CC BY-SA 3.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons

Magnetic field readings “varied from 47,018–51,588 nT, SD from 4–32 nT. All of these measurements are within the natural fluctuation ranges and are not inherently anomalous.” Light level directly outside the vault, floorspace and height were positively correlated with the Haunted Order; mean experiences were positively correlated with exterior light levels and height. [source]

Keep exploring

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this hauntings desk?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next unexplained.im site get built.